The Legal Risks of Reposting User-Generated Content
Somebody posts a great photo. Maybe it's a happy client holding up their paperwork, a law firm thanking you by name, or a video of a process server handling a tough situation like a pro. Your first instinct is to grab it and share it on your business page. It's free, it's real, and it makes you look good.
Hold on a second.
Just because something is public doesn't mean it's yours to use. That photo has an owner. The people in it have rights. The words in that post might not even be true. And when you put it on your business account, you're not just sharing it anymore. You're publishing it, under your name, to promote your company.
User-generated content, or UGC, is one of the best marketing tools out there. Customer photos, reviews, videos, testimonials, comments, and social posts make a business feel real in a way polished ads never will. For process servers and legal support folks, it can also help educate the public and show off the work you actually do. But reposting it carelessly can open you up to copyright claims, privacy problems, false endorsement issues, defamation, platform violations, and a black eye with the very clients you're trying to impress.
Let's walk through how to use it the right way.
What Counts as User-Generated Content
UGC is anything created by somebody other than you or your marketing team. Written posts, photos, videos, drawings, reviews, livestream clips, forum comments, audio recordings, memes. If a customer, follower, employee, or random stranger made it, it's UGC.
Social platforms and review sites run on this stuff because people trust other people more than they trust a brand. That's the whole appeal. But here's the part most business owners miss. The person who made it usually still owns it. A public post can be viewed, liked, and commented on. That does not mean you can download it, edit it, slap your logo on it, and run it in an ad.
The Main Risks of Reposting UGC
Before we get into the details, here's what can actually go wrong when you repost content you don't have the rights to:
Copyright infringement from copying, displaying, sharing, or editing someone's work without permission
Privacy or right of publicity claims involving someone's name, face, voice, location, or personal information
Defamation when the post you shared says something false and damaging about a person or business
False endorsement when your use makes it look like someone backs your company when they never agreed to
Advertising violations when a testimonial gets edited, can't be backed up, or is missing a required disclosure
Breaking the platform's rules or going past what the creator actually agreed to
The fallout ranges from an annoyed DM to a takedown demand, a suspended account, legal fees, damages, or a bad reputation. Even if nobody ever sues you, one angry creator posting "this company stole my photo" can do real damage in a small industry where everybody talks.
Copyright Comes First
Copyright is usually the first thing to think about. In the United States, an original photo, video, drawing, or piece of writing is protected by copyright the moment it's created and saved in some fixed form. The creator doesn't have to register it. They don't have to put a little copyright symbol on it. It's protected either way.
Under 17 U.S.C. § 106, the copyright owner controls who gets to copy the work, distribute it, display it publicly, and make new versions of it. So when you download a photo and upload it to your business page, you've made a copy and displayed it publicly. When you crop it, add text, or cut a video into a promo reel, you may be making a new version. Each of those is a right that belongs to the owner, not you.
Here's where it gets real. Registration isn't needed for copyright to exist, but a U.S. owner generally needs to register before filing a lawsuit, and registering early opens the door to statutory damages. For willful infringement, statutory damages can go as high as $150,000 per work under 17 U.S.C. § 504(c). That's a terrible price to pay for a Facebook post that got 14 likes.
Who Actually Owns It?
Ownership gets messy fast. The person in the photo usually isn't the person who took it. Say your client's wife snapped a picture of him in front of the courthouse. He's in it. She owns it. Getting his okay doesn't cover her rights.
Same with video. Somebody might own the footage, but the song playing in the background belongs to a record label. Permission from the account holder won't fix that if they don't control every piece of what's in the post.
So before you repost anything, ask yourself one question. Does the person giving me permission actually own all of this?
What About Fair Use?
People love to throw out "fair use" like it's a magic shield. It's not.
Fair use, under 17 U.S.C. § 107, can allow some unlicensed uses for things like criticism, commentary, news reporting, teaching, scholarship, or research. But courts decide it case by case using four factors: the purpose of the use, the nature of the work, how much was taken, and the effect on the market for the original. There's no blanket social media exception.
And here's the part that matters for you. A business reposting someone's photo to promote its own services is a commercial use. That's a lot harder to defend than, say, a short clip you're actually breaking down and commenting on in an educational post. If your whole plan depends on fair use, you need a lawyer, not a hunch.
Can You Repost Without Permission?
My practical rule is simple. Get permission first.
Could some exception or defense cover you in a particular situation? Maybe. But assuming a public post is free for you to use commercially is asking for trouble you don't need.
A few things that do NOT count as permission:
Tagging or crediting the creator. Giving credit tells people where it came from. It doesn't give you a license. "Photo by @whoever" is polite, but it's not consent.
No copyright notice. As I said, protection exists automatically. No symbol doesn't mean no owner.
"Everybody does it." Yep. And everybody who gets a takedown demand says the same thing.
There's also a difference between using the platform's built-in share button and downloading the file and uploading it yourself. The share or retweet feature usually works inside the platform's own terms, and the original post stays attached to the creator. Downloading and reuploading is a whole new copy on your account. Platform terms generally give the platform a license to host and display what users post. They don't automatically hand every business on the platform its own license to reuse it. Read the current terms of whatever platform you're on, because they change.
Permission Has to Match the Use
This is where a lot of businesses get caught. Somebody says "sure, you can share that" in a comment. Great. That covers a share. Does it cover a paid Facebook ad? Your website homepage? A printed brochure you hand out at the bar association luncheon? An email blast six months from now?
Probably not. Permission to share a photo once in an Instagram Story is not permission to use it everywhere forever. When you ask, be specific about where it's going and for how long.
Privacy and Publicity: The Person in the Picture
Copyright protects the creative work. Privacy and publicity laws protect the person. Those are two different things, and you need to clear both.
Depending on the state, using someone's name, face, voice, or identity for commercial purposes without their consent can create its own separate claim. California Civil Code § 3344 is a good example. It covers knowingly using someone's name, voice, signature, photograph, or likeness to advertise or sell without their consent, and it sets a minimum of $750 in damages, plus more if actual damages are higher. Other states have their own versions, so check where you do business.
That means getting the photographer's okay may not be enough. If somebody recognizable is in the shot, you want a release from them too.
Be extra careful with anything involving:
Kids
Health or medical information
Schools, homes, or workplaces
Exact locations or addresses
And look at the background, not just the subject. You'd be amazed what shows up in the background of a photo: mail on the counter, a laptop screen open, an ID badge on a lanyard, a license plate in the driveway, or a court document sitting right there on the table. For most businesses that's sloppy. For a process server, that could be somebody's safety.
Defamation: You Own What You Amplify
Reposting doesn't get you off the hook for what the post says.
Say someone posts that a certain landlord is a slumlord who illegally evicts people, and you share it because it relates to an eviction you just served. If that statement is false and damaging, you just pushed it to your whole audience under your company's name. You made the harm bigger.
Some people will tell you federal law protects you because you didn't write it. Don't build your business on that. Those protections have limits, they don't cover your own added comments, and they don't help you at all with copyright. The smarter move is to never repost anything that makes factual claims about a real person or business unless you know it's true.
For process servers, this matters even more. Posts that name opposing parties, clients, witnesses, or the people you served should get a hard look. Honestly, most of the time they shouldn't be posted at all.
Advertising Rules and Testimonials
A repost can turn misleading the second you rip it out of its original context. If you take a customer quote about one service and pair it with a photo of a different service, you may have changed what they actually said. That's a problem.
In the United States, the Federal Trade Commission's Guides Concerning the Use of Endorsements and Testimonials in Advertising, found at 16 C.F.R. Part 255, say endorsements have to reflect the honest opinions of the person giving them. If there's a material connection between you and the person, like you paid them, gave them a free serve, they work for you, or they're your cousin, that connection generally has to be clearly disclosed.
The FTC also adopted a rule in 2024, 16 C.F.R. Part 465, that targets fake reviews and testimonials, including reviews that misrepresent who wrote them or what the reviewer actually experienced. So no inventing reviews, no "improving" a real one, and no cherry-picking a single great quote and making it sound like it's about something it wasn't.
And don't promise results. If a review says "they served my ex in two hours," you can share that as one person's experience. You can't turn it into an ad that says "we serve everyone in two hours." That's a claim you'd have to back up.
Why Process Servers Need Tighter Rules
Every business should be careful with UGC. Process servers need to be careful times ten.
Think about what we handle every day. Case information. Home addresses. Schedules. Names of people going through divorces, evictions, restraining orders, lawsuits. One careless post can expose a client, put a server in danger, or make it look like you're mocking someone who's having the worst week of their life. And the attorneys who hire you are watching. If you're loose with somebody else's information on social media, why would they trust you with theirs?
Here are the content rules I'd follow:
Never reveal confidential client information or anything about a case that isn't public.
Check every photo and video for addresses, faces, license plates, court documents, screens, and location data before it goes anywhere.
Never post anything that harasses, ridicules, threatens, or prejudges anyone involved in a legal matter. Not the person you served, not the opposing party, nobody.
Confirm who owns it, get written permission, and get releases from any recognizable person in anything used commercially.
Verify any factual claim, and keep your licenses, approvals, releases, and disclosures on file.
Talk to a lawyer when the content involves minors, sensitive facts, unclear ownership, or a bigger advertising campaign.
Follow those and you can still do great marketing. You just won't be the cautionary tale somebody else writes about.
A Quick Word on Location Data
This one deserves its own spot. Photos taken on a phone can carry hidden location information in the file. Many platforms strip that data when you upload, but not every place you share a file does it, and not every app behaves the same way. If you're posting a photo from a job, or sharing one a client sent you, strip the location data first or take a screenshot of it instead. And remember that even with the data stripped, the picture itself can give away a location. A street sign, a house number, or a recognizable building does the same job.
A Simple Workflow for Reposting UGC the Right Way
If you want to use customer content without the headaches, you need a process you repeat every single time. Here's the one I'd use.
1. Figure Out Who Made It and Who's In It
Who took the photo or shot the video? Who's in it? Is there music, artwork, a logo, or anyone else's work showing? Every one of those can have its own owner.
2. Ask for Permission in Writing
A comment that says "go for it" is better than nothing, but a short written message or email is better. Spell out exactly what you want to use and where it's going. Organic social posts? Paid ads? Your website? Email? Print? Say it.
Something as simple as this works: "Hi, we love this photo. Can Mighty Process Server share it on our Facebook, Instagram, and website, with credit to you? We'd also like to use it in paid ads for the next 12 months. Is that okay?"
3. Define the License Clearly
Write down the platforms, how long you can use it, where (local, statewide, everywhere), whether you can edit or crop it, how they want to be credited, and whether anyone else, like a marketing vendor, can use it. Permission for one thing is not permission for everything.
4. Keep the Original Meaning Intact
Don't twist what the creator said or did. If you want to make big edits, show them first and get their okay. If there was a disclosure in the original, like "I got a free serve for this review," keep it.
5. Keep Good Records
Save the request, their reply, the exact content they approved, their account name, and any conditions. Put it all in one place, a simple spreadsheet or folder works fine. If a question ever comes up a year from now, you can pull it up in thirty seconds instead of scrolling through old DMs hoping you find it.
6. Have a Plan for Complaints and Takedowns
Pick one person who handles it when somebody says "take that down," when there's a dispute about who owns something, or when there's a privacy concern. Respond fast. Pulling a post the same day someone asks costs you nothing. Arguing about it can cost you plenty.
What This Looks Like Day to Day
Let me give you a couple of quick examples so this isn't all theory.
An Attorney Shares a Thank-You
A happy attorney posts on LinkedIn thanking your team for a tough serve. You want to share it. Using LinkedIn's own share or repost feature with a thank-you comment is pretty low risk, because it stays attached to their original post. Want to screenshot it and put it on your website as a testimonial? Send them a quick message and ask. Most people say yes, and now you've got it in writing.
A Client Sends a Photo
A client sends you a photo of themselves holding their filed proof of service, all smiles. Great moment. But that document has a case number, names, and maybe an address on it. Even with their permission, blur it or skip it. Their happiness doesn't cancel out the other party's privacy.
A Server Posts Job Footage
One of your servers posts a funny video of a dog chasing them off a porch. It might go viral. It also might show the house, the street, and the person you were there to serve. That's not content. That's a problem. Keep job footage off social media, period, unless it's been completely scrubbed and you've thought hard about it.
A Customer Leaves a Google Review
Someone leaves a glowing Google review. You want to turn it into a graphic for Instagram. Quote it word for word, don't edit it to sound better, and if that reviewer has any connection to your business, disclose it. If you're unsure, ask them if it's okay to feature it.
Use Customer Content With Clear Permission
None of this means you should stop using customer content. UGC is honest, it's relatable, and it works. It just means you need to treat it like what it is, somebody else's property and somebody else's story.
The rules really aren't complicated. Figure out who owns it. Ask for clear permission. Agree on how you'll use it. Keep the original meaning. Give credit. Write it all down.
For process servers and legal professionals, the bar is higher, because our work lives in private information and stressful moments for real people. Build a simple permission system, scrub everything before it goes out, and bring in a lawyer when things get gray. Do that, and customer content becomes one of your best marketing assets instead of your next legal headache.
Stay sharp. Stay informed. Live Mighty!
Read the full article at www.mightyprocessserver.com
This article is published by Process Server Daily, powered by MightyAutomation.ai, the leader in legal support intelligence.
