Handling Multiple Defendants at the Same Address
Two names, one house. Sounds like a two-for-one. It usually isn't.
Here's the setup I see all the time. Say it's Jeff and Thea, husband and wife, both named. Jeff always answers the door. Thea never does. Jeff has figured out a plan: every time you show up, he says "No, you have to give it to her." He thinks he's winning.
He's not. He just doesn't know how I plan a sub-serve.
One person, one set of papers
First rule. Every defendant gets their own complete set. Two defendants, two packets. A married couple doesn't share a summons. If a business is also named at that address, that's a third packet, even if the guy who owns the business is standing right there.
Label them before you leave. Name on the front of each one, in big letters, so you're not flipping pages on the porch while Jeff closes the door.
And every defendant gets their own proof of service. One proof covering "the residents" is how a default gets set aside later.
Plan the diligence, then plan the serve
Some states require a certain number of attempts before you can leave papers with another adult at the home. So if I already know both of them work during the day, I make my attempts during the day. Once in the morning when I'm in the area, once around lunch, on different days. Easy attempts. I know they're not home. I log them and drive off.
Then on the attempt that counts, I go when I know they're home.
Now when Jeff opens the door, I don't need Thea to come out. I've got my diligence. I can sub-serve whoever answers. Jeff's been saying "No, you have to give it to her" for two weeks, and now he answers the door and bam, he's holding his papers and hers.
That's not a trick. That's just planning. Check your state's rules on the number of attempts and who qualifies for substitute service before you rely on it, because they really do vary.
If he doesn't answer? Then maybe I go to work. Maybe I use the stalking method and catch them going from one place to another. The best way to get people is when they're going from one place to another. It really is.
All other occupants
Evictions are the other big multi-name job. In California there's a catch-all for anybody else living there that isn't named, called "all other occupants." When I posted one, I'd tape it up, take a date and time stamped photo of it, and move on. That photo goes in the file. An eviction is linear. The notice comes first, and it's the most contested thing in court.
Your state may handle unnamed occupants completely differently. Ask the attorney how they want it done.
Don't make the house a crowd scene
When several people in one home are being sued, there's usually something ugly going on. Divorce, a family business that went bad, an eviction. Don't announce the case on the porch. Don't read names out loud for the whole family. Hand it over, say those are legal documents, and leave. There's only pain in sticking around.
And never, ever ask a kid to go get mom and dad for this. Don't ever ask a child to solve adult problems.
Tell the client what you got
If you got Jeff but not Thea, say so the same day. "Served one of two, here's my plan for the second." That's all an attorney wants. Serve the paper, sign the proof, communicate status.
Be safe out there.
Stay sharp. Stay informed. Live Mighty!
Read the full article at www.mightyprocessserver.com
This article is published by Process Server Daily, powered by MightyAutomation.ai, the leader in legal support intelligence.
